8 Best Broiler Pans for Perfect Roasting and Grilling

Last Updated on September 2, 2023 by Emily Anna

The use of broiling pan in cooking is must on daily basis because of its potential advantages. It is an ideal kitchen tool for getting perfectly cooked and browned food. However, finding the best Broiler pan can be challenging at times. 

People usually want a broiling pan that is simple to use and fast to cook dishes like steaks, veggies, and meat. They want it to bring them the healthiest dishes and crisp brown color. 

Moreover, pan should have a nonstick surface that results in easy release of cooked food and cleaning afterward. This way, you may enjoy your food more and clean up less.

Granite Ware 3 Broiler Pan is a versatile kitchen tool that fits all these requirements. This multi-functional cookware is not only for broiling and grilling but also perfect for baking. Furthermore, this pan has a nonstick surface that is not toxic. Moreover, it’s big enough for anything you cook and easily fits in your small cabinet.

Along with this item, many other options are available, each with unique characteristics. Hence, after extensive research and testing, I have listed some products similar to the one mentioned above.These set of pans are listed according to the needs and preferences of different types of users. 

Best Broiler Pans review

1 GE WB48X10056 Pan

This general electric model is a good choice if you want a long-lasting and heavy-duty performance from your Pan. It is a 2 piece black Porcelain broiler Pan that is super easy to handle. 

It has a roasting rack set that holds food above the grid, allowing air to circulate completely around all surfaces. This accessory provides a stable cooking surface, letting juices drain into the Pan below. 

However, the broiler pan’s edges are sharp, making cleaning hard. Also, the cooked stuff may not come off in the dishwasher and requires hand scrubbing with a brass bristle brush.

Besides this, it is 12-3/4 inches wide, 1-1/4 inches high, and 16-1/2 inches long. It is a big pan with lots of capacity, making it ideal to feed a large group. Additionally, the size of this Pan is perfect for most ovens. 

It is oven or gas and electric stove safe, so you would not have any issues with its performance. Moreover, It can be used for various applications, including cooking beef, chicken, fish, pork, roasts, lamb, and veggies. 

Pros:

• Easy to use 
• Thick gauge steel with an excellent coating
• Sturdy Pan
• Cleaned up with minimal effort
• Distributes heat evenly
• High heat resistant 

Cons:

• Edges are sharp
• Due to complicated design, food tends to stick to it

2 Whirlpool 4396923

Whirlpool 4396923 has perfect broiling features to boil anything. It is one of the best Broiler pans for cooking healthy meals quickly and conveniently. This item is a durable stainless steel Broiler Pan made of sturdy porcelain. That’s why it cooks meals with consistent results.

It heats up easily and evenly distributes the heat. Hence, it results in even cooking every time. Also, the nonstick coat allows easy food release. However, the coating may peel off on scrubbing or after washing multiple times. Unfortunately, it is only guaranteed to fit some Whirlpool ovens.

Moreover, this Pan is 16-3/4″ long, 12-3/4″ wide, and 1-1/2″ high, but this size may be small for a whole slab. It features a considerable measure to accommodate a large amount of food. In addition, the upper part has several holes that help drain excess oil. In this way, it avoids the production of smoke and splatter.

Unlike the GE WB48X10056 Pan, it has smooth edges that make it easy to use. It does not have sharp edges around drain holes, so it is easy to scrub without cutting yourself. Additionally, it is dishwasher compatible.

Pros:

• High-Quality, Durable Pan
• Made of nonstick material 
• Lightweight
• There are no sharp edges
• Visual appearance is excellent
• Dishwasher compatible 
• No splatter and smoke

Cons:

• Pretty small for a full slab
• The coating may start to chip over 

3 Range Kleen BP106X

Range Kleen BP106X is a two-piece set featuring high-duty steel Broil and Bake Pan. Moreover, this USA-made small broiler pan set has exceptional heat tolerance capacity. You might be amazed that it is safe for use for up to 1025 degrees F. 

If you use a standard pan, you will notice that it can warp under the extreme heating of the boiler. At the same time, this particular Pan does not warp even at high temperatures and lasts much longer.

The base of this model is made up of top-notch porcelain, while the grill is made up of superior steel. Furthermore, it has an FOA and PTFE-free nonstick surface. So no harmful chemicals are used in finishing this nonstick broiler pan. 

As a result, you can enjoy a healthier, delicious meal every time. Moreover, it comes with a grate to drip off excess fats easily. However, it may be challenging to get rid of the grease. You may need to wash it with hot water.

Unlike the Whirlpool 4396923 and GE WB48X10056 Pan, this Broiler pan can be used as a baking dish. So, this kitchenware is also ideal for broiling and baking dishes such as cakes, desserts, lasagna, and more. 

Furthermore, due to its small size, it is also suitable for use on an outdoor grill. If you want to enjoy barbequing outside with your family, this product is worth looking into. This boiler pan is for wide purposed like camping, boating, and smaller ranges.  

Pros:

• Perfect size for a little countertop oven
• Handles heat well
• No harmful chemicals are used
• Heavy-duty steel is used
• Cleans up well in the dishwasher
• A Versatile pan for multiple functions
• It can be used for baking as well

Cons:

• Challenging to get rid of the grease
• It may show rust spots after some time

4 Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster 

Farberware Nonstick Steel Roaster is a beautiful addition to any kitchen. Moreover, this roasting Pan has a chrome-plated rack. This rack makes it perfect for roasting meat, allowing excess fats to pass down to the lower tray. It can also be used for roasting fish and vegetables. 

Furthermore, it has wide, dual-riveted cast stainless steel handles on the roasting Pan. They are further chrome pleated for added comfort and efficacy. They make it easier to remove it from the oven.

However, the handles get warmer when working at high flame. Also, I found using the handles challenging as they interfere with putting the Pan in the oven.

Nevertheless, it is a cast iron broiler pan that can be used in ovens up to 450 F. However, it has a very slippery bottom. So it would be best to be careful when removing it from the oven.

Besides this, it heats evenly to help reduce heat spots that can burn food. Although, this pan is designed to resist warping for years of roasting performance, the nonstick coating may start to come out after some time.

If handled carefully, this large broiler Pan is perfect for family-sized deep dishes, including casseroles, enchiladas, and more. Also, it is a versatile kitchenware that can make turkey, lasagna, and shepherd’s pie.

Pros:

• Heats up evenly
• Built solidly without being heavy
• Cleanup is super easy
• Cery sturdy and heavy gauge
• Extremely versatile, Long-lasting Pan
• It has stainless steel rack
• Handles can fold down for easy, compact storage 

Cons

• The nonstick coating may peel off
• A very slippery bottom
• The handles may interfere with putting the Pan in the oven

5 Granite Ware 3 Broiler Pan

Granite Ware 3 Broiler Pan is a 3-piece set with one baking dish, one broiling dish, and one grilling dish. Furthermore, these independent components can be combined to make a thrilling trio.

The baking tray serves as a drip tray while broiling or grilling with this equipment. This results in wonderfully juicy and crispy chicken parts that have not been sitting in their fat. 

Secondly, all of the product components have a carbon steel core. This makes them more energy efficient since they heat up faster and can serve good results at lower temperatures.

That is why it is the best Broiler pan that browns better and cooks more evenly than any other roaster. The notable thing is that if exposed to high temperatures it may get warped.

The outside of this roaster and baking pan is covered with porcelain enamel. It is due to this feature that it has a nonstick surface. Moreover, it is a food-safe stainless steel broiler pan that is long-lasting. 

So this versatile kitchen tool is an excellent addition to your summer BBQs. It is very compact, so you can quickly transfer it anywhere. All above, it is an economical and best-fitted item for its purpose. 

Pros:

• Built sturdy 
• Versatile and multi-functional Pan
• Perfect for small apt stoves
• Comes with two grilling surfaces – the metal grill and the granite grill
• Perforated sheet on top of the Pan allows better air & heat circulation

Cons:

• Smaller than a standard broiler pan
• It may get warped at high temperature 

6 Norpro Nonstick Broil Pan

If you live in a congested apartment with your friend and want space-efficient kitchenware, the Norpro Nonstick Broil pan is for you. It is the best small broiler pan, measuring 16.5 x 12 x 2 inches, and will easily fit in your capsule kitchen. 

But don’t underestimate its size; the pan has enough cooking surface to fulfill your broiling, roasting, and baking needs. It is a two-piece set with a rack, offering enough space for air to circulate the food. This results in the crispy texture of your food in no time. When served, the food is not just browned but evenly cooked as well. 

As the pan has little perforated squares, this design makes cleaning a hassle. You have to scrub each square individually to remove leftover foodstuff. To avoid this inconvenience, cover the top with aluminum foil and make holes in the foil to match the holes in those squares. 

Another major drawback of this pan is that the nonstick coating needs to be more durable. Hence, looking for something to use in restaurants or other similar places is not recommended. But the Norpro is the best broiling pan for home cooks at a reasonable price. 

However, you must be careful when using it, even at home. Always use it on medium flame and avoid using metal utensils for its long life. 

Pros:

• Small sized but has a good cooking surface area
• Reasonably priced
• Heats up evenly 
• Has nostril design

Cons:

• Not for market use
• Cleaning is not easy 

7 Wilton Baking Pan

The steel construction of this pan ensures that it can withstand high temperatures while maintaining its structural integrity. So, Wilton Baking Pan is another best pan that offers sturdiness and longevity. 

It is also a two-piece pan set, and the upper tray has a unique diagonal trough and crest design. The trough has small holes allowing excess oil to pass down in the lower pan. Moreover, the top fits well in the rack. It is designed to maintain an appropriate distance between food and the broiler element or oven, allowing direct heating.

The bottom is 2.23 inches high and can be used exceptionally for baking. As far as the nonstick coating is concerned, only the top tray has it. The lower drip pan is not finished with any nonstick coating and may start to rust if used frequently. So, line it with foil or parchment to avoid any staining.

Its small size makes it the best broiler pan for the oven. It measures 13× 8 inches, including the handles, which is good for individual servings or smaller family meals. Despite being compact, it can not be placed in a toaster oven. 

Fortunately, this Baking Pan is also dishwasher safe; hand washing should be the priority. 

Pros:

• Well-designed and constructed
• Best size pan for standard ovens
• The top sits firmly in place
• Long-lasting and durable 
• Dishwasher safe

Cons :

• The drip pan may get stains
• It cannot fit in a toaster oven

8 CHEFMADE Roasting Pan

Some brands often overlook the presentation of cookware. But CHEFMADE has addressed this aspect. The champagne gold color of CHEFMADE Roasting Pan will keep you fresh while working with it.  

Besides its aesthetics, this multitasker tool can be used for everything from bacon to roasts. It is a shallow pan with a wire rack of carbon steel. The benefit of this wire rack is that it allows maximum heat to reach the food. 

As a result, it shortens the broiling time and facilitates optimal crisping and browning of the meal. In addition, due to its steel construction, it heats up quickly and evenly, becoming the best pan for broiling. 

Furthermore, it has a thick, nonstick coating on the pan and the wire rack. This coating also makes it an ideal Teflon-free pan as no harmful chemical like PTFE and PFOA is used in its surface coating. This feature makes the cookware safe to use in an oven up to 430°C. Also, it is scratch and rust-resistant, hence durable. 

A downside of this product is that it does not have side handles. Though it has extended edges, the pan is difficult to remove from the oven after baking or broiling. The reason is that the edges do not support its weight as it is a little heavy. 

The design and the nonstick coating both make the cleaning process easy. Steak also tastes better when you know the clean-up will be quick and easy. 

Pros:

• Pretty colored multitasker kitchenware
• Healthy and durable nonstick coating 
• Best to use in the oven up to 430°C
• The set includes a shallow pan with a wire rack

Cons:

• A little heavy
• It does not have side handles 

FAQs

Conclusion 

A broiler pan is the best cooking tool to enhance your cooking experience. Its ability to reduce fat and achieve crispiness is becoming popular among people. Due to its increasing use in the kitchen, finding one of the best Broiler pans to enjoy healthy eating is essential. 

Furthermore, ensuring a high-quality pan for a healthy and delicious meal is crucial. The above is a list of broiler pans that are durable, sturdy, and easy to use. They can help you have a nice cooking experience. All of them are recommended after testing and reviewing the products.

However, if you want a pan that allows you to perform multiple tasks, Granite Ware 3 Broiler Pan can be an excellent addition to your small kitchen. The dark interior of this specific Pan absorbs the oven’s energy and distributes heat evenly. 

Moreover, you can carry it anywhere due to its supportive weight and design. It is highly economical and the best option for a lower budget.